Contesting a criterion: the advisor's right of reply to their evaluation

In most quality monitoring setups, the evaluated person never had a say. Contesting a criterion gives the advisor a structured right of reply: they propose the value they believe is fair on a criterion of their own evaluation, justify it, and a manager arbitrates (validate or reject). The AI analysis stays the common base, the advisor's request and the manager's decision are added to it, traced. Not to be confused with deactivating a whole evaluation. The right of reply, a sign of mature, shared quality monitoring.

An agent disputing an evaluation criterion

Key takeaways on contesting a criterion

  • Quality monitoring has long made the evaluated person a passive subject. Contesting a criterion gives them their voice back.
  • Contesting a criterion means, for the advisor, proposing the value they believe is fair on a criterion of their own evaluation, and justifying it.
  • The manager arbitrates: they validate, and the proposal applies, or they reject, and the score stays unchanged. Every arbitration is traced.
  • Contesting a criterion is not deactivating a whole evaluation: here, you discuss a specific score, not the scope of monitoring.
  • The AI analysis stays visible: the advisor's request and the manager's decision are added next to it, never instead of it.
  • This is human oversight made very concrete: giving a right of reply to the evaluated person.

In quality monitoring, the evaluated person was long a mere subject

In most quality monitoring setups, the evaluated person never really had a say. A score lands, sometimes commented, rarely discussed. The advisor receives it, full stop. This asymmetry has a well-known cost for managers: people do not buy into an evaluation they merely undergo.

AI conversational analysis changes things on a decisive point: it offers everyone the same base, objective and consistent, applied the same way to every conversation. What remains is to give the evaluated person the means to respond. That is exactly the role of the right to contest a criterion: letting the advisor make their point heard, and the manager settle it, while keeping a trace of everything.

Giving a right of reply, without destabilising the system

The risk of a "right of reply" would be to open an endless complaints box. Contestation is designed the opposite way: structured and targeted.

The advisor does not contest their score as a block. They take a specific criterion, propose the value they think they deserve, and explain why: an element of context, a light shed on the exchange, a piece of information the analysis did not have. The common base produced by the AI is not called into question: it serves as the anchor for a discussion on the few points where the advisor's lived experience adds something.

The advisor proposes, the manager arbitrates

A contestation is not a remark that gets lost: it is the start of a decision. The advisor proposes a value and justifies it; a manager arbitrates.

The arbitration is simple and unambiguous: validating means accepting the value proposed by the advisor, which then applies to the evaluation; rejecting means keeping the original score, while explaining why. Each contested criterion follows its own cycle: pending arbitration, validated, or rejected. As long as nothing is settled, the score does not move.

Where modifying an evaluation is a direct decision by the manager, contestation comes from the advisor. Two complementary paths to the same fair and shared score: one comes down from the manager, the other rises from the field.

Contesting a criterion is not deactivating an evaluation

The nuance matters, because the words look alike. Contesting a criterion means discussing a score inside an evaluation. Deactivating an evaluation from your monitoring is something else entirely: removing a whole conversation from quality monitoring, because it should not count (unusable recording, GDPR request, out of scope).

One is about the quality dialogue, the other about data governance. The two coexist, but do not overlap.

What the right of reply changes in the relationship

Giving the advisor the option to contest turns quality monitoring from a top-down exercise into a shared practice. The advisor knows their point of view counts and will be examined; the manager has a clear framework to settle matters, rather than handling informal contestations by email or in meetings.

The result is buy-in. A score that is discussed and arbitrated is better accepted than an imposed one, even when the arbitration does not side with the advisor. Contestation thus fits the same movement as the coaching debrief: making the evaluation a topic of conversation, not a verdict.

Who can contest, who arbitrates

The roles are clearly separated: you cannot be judge and party.

ActionAdministratorSupervisorAdvisor
Contest a criterion of one's own evaluation❌❌✅
Arbitrate a contestation (validate / reject)✅✅❌

The advisor can only contest the evaluations they are the subject of, and only a manager within their team scope arbitrates. Everyone knows who proposes and who decides.

Every arbitration leaves a trace

A validated contestation creates a new version of the evaluation, with its reason, its overall score, its date and its author. The advisor's request and the manager's decision stay viewable, alongside the AI's original analysis.

This traceability is not just a convenience: it is what lets you explain a score, to the advisor as much as to an auditor, and show that a human kept control of the final decision, in the sense of the human oversight expected from a responsible use of AI.

The right of reply, a sign of mature quality monitoring

An evaluation system is also judged by the room it leaves to the evaluated person. By giving the advisor a structured right to contest, and the manager a clear and traced arbitration framework, you move from undergone quality to shared quality, on a common analysis base produced by the AI.

Raisetalk evaluates 100% of your conversations and gives everyone, manager and advisor alike, their rightful place in the decision. To see how, discover automated quality monitoring or request access.

Blue tokens spread over a board divided into four zones, a single coral token set apart in one corner
Quality Monitoring 12 min

Evaluation disputes: what they tell you about your quality scorecard

A heavily disputed criterion is not necessarily a badly written one. Dispute rate and acceptance rate read criterion by criterion, the cause selected by the arbitrator, response time as a median: the method for knowing which criteria to review and which to explain, and how the Raisetalk Disputes report puts it into practice.

A row of blue chairs facing each other in pairs, one coral pair in the centre
Quality Monitoring 12 min

Tracking coaching: checking that debriefs take place, and what they change

Evaluating is not coaching. The number of debriefs says neither whether they were completed nor which advisors were seen. Stages, times as a median, team coverage, criteria worked on before and after: the method for tracking coaching, and how the Raisetalk Debriefs report puts it into practice.

A queue of blue call bubbles, two of them coral and joined by an arc
Quality Monitoring 14 min

First call resolution rate: measuring it on your customers' real callbacks

A customer who calls back about the same thing was not served on the first call. Advisor-entered status, instant survey, same number within 7 days: the usual FCR measures mislead. The method for a reliable rate, and how Once & Done in Raisetalk applies it to 100% of calls.

A coral speech bubble with jagged edges, picked out in the middle of a stream of blue bubbles
Use Case 12 min

Customer incivility: identifying it in calls to alert and support advisors

An angry customer is not an uncivil customer. Insults, threats, discriminatory remarks: incivility targets the advisor as a person, and most of the time it goes unnoticed. A three-step method to identify it on 100% of calls, alert the right manager and support teams, without measuring emotion.

Three screens of the new Raisetalk interface: dashboard, evaluation page, contestation panel
Conversational Analysis 7 min

The new Raisetalk interface: conversational analysis moves up another gear

Raisetalk unveils its new interface, delivered the weekend of 1 November: more modern, clearer and, above all, more productive, built on the foundations that make it strong. A dashboard for every role, every score proven in one click, one way to search everywhere, and everything you rely on still in place.

A coral label is tied by four threads to four distinct objects set side by side
Quality Monitoring 16 min

Quality monitoring: what the term really covers, and why two tools carrying that label do not do the same job

Scoring advisors, checking regulatory compliance, listening to the voice of the customer, coaching a sales force: four disciplines circulate under the "quality monitoring" label. They do not have the same users, the same scorecards or the same standards of proof. The framework for telling them apart, why a tool does not carry over from one to another, and how to write a specification that does not mix them up.

Upload a call. Read its analysis. Five minutes.

Sign up in seconds, with no credit card and no cookies. A welcome tour walks you through the key principles, then you add your first conversation.

Early access · Your feedback shapes the product